Blog | Regulation of Labour Welfare and Wages in Pakistan

1. The Significance of Wage Legislation

Wages are not only crucial determinants of family income levels, but also of social justice, economic resilience, and social solidarity. In Pakistan, informal employment represents nearly 64% of economic activity. Without strong wage protection, the most vulnerable workers—domestic workers, casual workers, and women working in informal economies—are subject to greater financial and social vulnerabilities.

2. Pakistan Regulatory Framework

Framework for Minimum Wage

Provincial Variation: In Sindh and Punjab, legally the minimum wage is PKR 37,000/month in 2024. But the vast majority earn much less than that.
Unequal Enforcement: More than 80% of Sindh’s industries do not comply with minimum wage laws; but disproportionately low numbers of members of the population are penalized.
Offenses in the Private Sector: In Rawalpindi, offenses remain overwhelmingly prevalent and largely unreported, despite public enforcement activity that has yielded fines and arrears.

B. Safeguards and Vulnerabilities

Wages Protection Act (2019): Requires formal notice wage systems, with uneven enforcement and some employers evading requirements.
Working Hours & Overtime: On paper, the maximum is 8–9 hours/day, but staff often work 10–12 hours unpaid for overtime.
Coverage & Enforcement: Only one labor inspector exists per 250,000–500,000 workers in Pakistan, far less than the ILO norm of 1:10,000. Provincial labor bureaus remain underfunded and understaffed.
Union Barriers: Even if unions are legal, their establishment is often discouraged by bureaucratic processes and employer intimidation.
Gender & Informality Gaps: Women earn 30–50% less than men, and an enormous majority of employees never receive legally mandated wage increases.

3. Community Level Insights

Websites document widespread disillusion and disaffection. Low-wage workers report serious violations of wage law, the lack of complaint procedures, and the acceptance of underpayment, even in major cities.

4. International Comparisons: Best Practices

• Brazil: Ties minimum wage reform to conditional cash transfers to fight poverty while increasing the effectiveness of the wage floor.
• Germany: Compulsory compliance is achieved through rigorous inspection protocols, worker hotlines, and severe penalties.

United States: Enforces federal law for overtime to guard employees against working too much beyond the standard 40-hour week.

5. Principal Challenges

6. Policy Recommendations

A. Federated Minimum Wage Board

Analysis:

• Inspector shortages and the rollback of unannounced inspections since 2003 have weakened oversight.
  
  
• Approximately 64% of labor operates outside formal structures and wage regulation.
  
  
• Legal sanctions for noncompliance are low and inconsistently applied.
  
  
• The statutory minimum wage falls short of the estimated PKR 75,000/month needed for a basic living.
  
  
• Systemic disparities in earnings exist based on gender and geographic location.
  
  

Recommendation: There should be a three-party federal-provincial board, which reviews and adjusts minimum wage rates periodically based on inflation and industry needs.

B. Approaches to Implementation

• Grow Inspectorate: Employ and train adequate labor inspectors to meet international standards.
  
  
• Surprise Visits: Restore surprise visits to factories to deter non-compliance.
  
  
• Hotlines and Digital Tools: Create complaint-friendly platforms and monitoring software for pay designed for employees.
  
  
• Increased Fines: Increase fines by company size and offense rate; suspend licenses if necessary.
  
  

C. Broaden Coverage to Extend to Informal Workers

• Worker Registration: Establish a national register of workers performing casual, gig, and home-based work.
  
  
• Legal Extensions: Extend minimum wage legislation and social insurance plans to non-conventional industries.
  
  

D. Gender and Living Wage Targets

• Living Wage Law Implementation: Implement a system for regionally based living wages.
  
  
• Gender Equity Enforcement: Implement wage audits and penalize discriminatory practices.
  
  
• Rural Incentives: Offer rate hikes in economically challenged or rural areas to help offset income disparities.
  
  

E. Draw Lessons from International Frameworks

• Comprehensive Welfare Frameworks: Combine schemes of compensation with economic assistance and access to health care.
  
  
• Labor Rights Education: Educate employees on their rights through government and NGO outreach.
  
  
• Rest and Overtime Protection: Ensure compliance with maximum working time and overtime payment.
  
  

7. Advocacy Strategies

• Mass Awareness Campaigns: Leverage radio, social media, and corporate seminars to raise awareness among employees regarding their rights.
  
  
• NGO–Union Coalitions: Organize grievance systems and legal clinics for marginalized workers.
  
  
• Documentation and Data Collection: Initiate yearly studies to assess wage compliance, which will guide reform.
  
  
• Experimental Pilot Projects for Policy Implementation: Launch experimental approaches, such as electronic notice of wages or mobile labor tribunals.
  
  

Conclusion

The Pakistani labor legislation is framed such that it delivers economic justice; however, this promise has been left unmet owing to numerous institutional weaknesses, coverage deficits, and existing socio-economic disparities. In the interest of fulfilling this promise, the state needs to strengthen its enforcement machinery, correct its policies according to international requirements, and expand its coverage of protection to the excluded and informal economies. Learning from best-practice international models, Pakistan has an imperative reform agenda that is morally as well as economically required in order to evolve.

Key References/Citations

1. The News International, 2024
   
   
2. Dawn’s editorials on labor policy
   
   
3. International Labour Organization (ILO) reports on Pakistan
   
   
4. ResearchGate analysis of wage enforcement in Pakistan
   
   
5. World Bank and UNDP investigations of employment in the informal sector
   
   
6. Germany’s Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs
   
   
7. U.S. Department of Labor policy brief.

____

Author: Farzam Ahmed
Member of Pak Youth Parliament